The dream of the self-driving car—you get in, program your destination, ease the seat back, and let the car take you where you need to go. Read a book. Maybe take a nap or play a game on the in-car entertainment screen. Regardless, you will not need to watch the road. The car will get you there and back safely.
Are we there yet? If not, when will we be?
Automation and autonomous driving are complex subjects. What engineers can safely deliver doesn’t always match what marketers want to sell.
This guide will walk you through what you need to know about automotive autopilot, self-driving technology, and driver aids today and tomorrow.
What is a Self-Driving Car?
When discussing automotive assistance systems’ terminology, no one agrees on what to call anything in this field. From engineering jargon to marketing speak, the language continues to evolve.
Roughly speaking, you can sort the technologies people might refer to as self-driving into two categories — driver support and automation systems. Read on to see how they differ.
Driver support technology reduces the workload on the driver. Today, most automakers sell various driver support systems, either as standard equipment or as options on their cars. These include intelligent or adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assists, and hands-free capability.
Autonomous systems do the driving for you. No automaker today sells a proper autonomous system, but some are pushing toward that technology. One such project underway is Waymo, a sister company to Google, testing autonomous rideshare vehicles in the U.S. using converted Chrysler Pacifica minivans.
Six Levels of Self-Driving Technology
The Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) has laid out a valuable framework for thinking about self-driving systems. They sort the technologies into six levels, labelled zero through five (okay, even automotive engineers don’t always do the logical thing).
However, not every level is classified as autonomous driving. According to the SAE, levels, zero through two are considered driver support features, while levels three through five are classified as autonomous capability.
At Level 0, the car reacts only to the driver’s input. Even if it uses sensors to warn you of surrounding traffic, like a blind-spot alert system or a lane-departure warning, it still has no self-driving capability to correct or counter the perceived threat.
At Level 1, your car can intervene slightly in your driving in an attempt to keep you safe. A lane-keeping system that helps steer to center you in a lane is a Level 1 technology.
At Level 2, features communicate with one another, and more than one can be active simultaneously. An example of this autonomous technology is an adaptive cruise control system that adjusts your speed to keep you a certain distance from the car ahead while centring the car in its lane.
Currently, Level 2 systems are the most sophisticated technology sold on cars in Canada. Some automakers describe these systems in ways that make them seem more advanced than Level 2 standards because they allow drivers to take their hands off the steering wheel briefly. However, all these systems require drivers to keep their eyes focused ahead. Drivers need to be ready at all times to take over control of the car at a moment’s notice.
At Level 3, the car can drive itself under limited conditions, but the driver must remain aware and prepared to take over. Automakers have tested Level 3 systems that will allow the driver to take their hands off the wheel in a traffic jam, for instance, but prompt the driver to take over when the congestion eases.
According to Honda and a few other reputable sites, the Honda 100 Legend Flagship car is the first Level 3 autonomous car. Right now, it’s only available in Japan for leasing. It was released on March 5, 2021.
There are no Level 3 systems currently sold to consumers in Canada or the U.S.
At Level 4, the car can drive itself in a fixed loop on known roads. The rider is not required to take over driving at any time. These vehicles may or may not have a steering wheel or pedals. In some places, Level 4 driverless rideshare vehicles (like Waymo’s) are in limited testing. But they are not yet approved for general use in Canada.
At Level 5, the car can drive itself under any conditions and on any road. These vehicles do not have steering wheels or pedals. At this point, Level 5 systems are theoretical.
Can You Trust It?
All self-driving systems currently for sale in Canada are SAE Level 2 or lower. It is not safe to remove your attention from driving while behind the wheel of any car currently sold with this technology. However, it is safe to briefly remove your hands from the wheel with some Level 2 systems under certain conditions. But it would be best if you remained prepared to take over the driving at a moment’s notice.
Tesla advertises its automation systems more aggressively than any other automaker. Still, its advertising materials flatly state, “Autopilot and Full Self-Driving Capability are intended for use with a fully attentive driver, who has their hands on the wheel and is prepared to take over at any moment. While these features are designed to become more capable over time, the currently enabled features do not make the vehicle autonomous.”
Do You Still Need to Pay Attention to the Road?
Yes. Always. Even when using driving assist technology in Levels 0 to 3, it’s required that you always keep your eyes on the road.
However, when using low-speed applications, including self-parking features, keeping your eyes on the road or staying inside the vehicle may not be needed. For example, some luxury brands offer a self-parking remote that handles this maneuver for things like parallel parking.
Which Cars Have Self-Driving Capability?
Virtually every automaker selling cars in Canada today offers driver-assistance systems that can reduce the workload on the driver. These include adaptive cruise control that can adjust speed to maintain distance from the car ahead or automatic emergency braking that can slow or stop the vehicle to avoid hitting a car or pedestrian or reduce the severity of a crash.
None of these systems are so reliable that the driver can take their attention from the task of driving, though.
Many manufacturers currently market systems up to and including Level 2 automation. This approach combines adaptive cruise control and lane-keeping assistance into a system that requires that the driver keep their hands on the wheel but relieves some of the driver’s workload.
A prime example is cruise control, with stop-and-go capability allowing the driver to negotiate heavy traffic without pedalling.
Here’s a breakdown of what to expect from several of them.
Nissan markets this as ProPILOT, “a hands-on driver-assist system that combines Nissan’s Intelligent Cruise Control and Steering Assist technologies. ProPilot includes a stop and hold function that can bring the vehicle to a full stop, hold in place, and can bring you back up to speed when traffic starts moving again.”
Newer versions use the vehicle’s navigation system information to slow for curves ahead and prompt the driver to adjust for posted speed limits. While it will keep the car centred in its lane, it will not steer the car through curves like Kia’s, Ford’s, General Motors’, or Tesla’s systems.
Subaru’s EyeSight system does much the same. It also has a pre-collision braking system that alerts the driver to an impending crash and applies full braking power to prevent it.
Volvo Pilot Assist
Volvo’s Pilot Assist allows the driver to set a preferred speed and preferred distance from the vehicle ahead. It can then change speed to maintain that distance and keep the car centred in its lane. But Pilot Assist will warn the driver audibly and shut itself off if the road starts to curve or if it detects that the driver has removed their hands from the wheel.
Mercedes-Benz Distronic Plus with Steering Assist
Mercedes-Benz’s Distronic Plus with Steering Assist also combines adaptive cruise control with a lane-centring system. In keeping with Mercedes’ autobahn image, it functions at up to 120 mph (193 km/h) and warns drivers if they are about to be passed.
Another feature, called Parktronic, allows drivers to follow the car’s commands under 20 mph (32 km/h) as it self-parks the vehicle. The driver keeps control of the car with the gas and brake pedals. The driver needs to put the car in drive or reverse as it drives and steers itself into a parking space.
Tesla Autopilot and Full Self-Driving
Tesla markets its evolving suite of self-driving technologies more aggressively than any other automaker. This has led to some confusion as to what level of automation Tesla cars are currently capable of. The electric car company sells the systems under two names: Autopilot and Full Self-Driving.
Every Tesla vehicle available in 2021 ships with the company’s Autopilot system enabled. Autopilot is a traffic-aware cruise control system that accelerates and slows the car to match the speed of the vehicles around it, combined with a lane-keeping assist system that centers the car in a marked lane. That’s all it is. The marketing name “Autopilot” may make it sound considerably more advanced. But it is similar to adaptive cruise control and lane-keeping assist systems offered by most automakers, like Nissan’s ProPILOT or Subaru’s EyeSight.
Older Teslas use torque sensors in the steering wheel to monitor the driver’s attention level and promptly alert them if their attention seems to be waning. Newer models use a more accurate camera for the same purpose.
Tesla’s Full Self-Driving is considerably more sophisticated. Despite its name, it does not possess SAE Level 5 self-driving capability. Full Self-Driving can park the car in a parking space, back it out of a parking space, and change lanes on its own at highway speeds. A more advanced system in beta testing can slow the car for stop signs and traffic lights and navigate highway on-ramps and off-ramps. Tesla regularly sends updates to this system remotely to cars currently involved in the beta test.
Crucially, Full Self-Driving does not allow the driver to take their attention from the road. They may temporarily take their hands from the wheel but should be prepared to take over driving at any moment. Tesla’s marketing materials caution, “The currently enabled Autopilot and Full Self-Driving features require active driver supervision and do not make the vehicle autonomous.”
Full Self-Driving is a costly option, even by luxury car standards. Tesla promises to update it regularly in hopes of eventually releasing an SAE Level 5 autonomous driving system to everyone who has purchased Full Self-Driving.
However, in a recent letter to California state regulators, Tesla said that Full Self-Driving would remain at Level 2. The company said it did “not expect significant enhancements” that would “shift the responsibility for the entire dynamic driving task to the system.” Instead, the letter said, Full Self-Driving “will continue to be an SAE Level 2, advanced driver assistance feature.”
Consumers should be aware that the company has told shoppers it will someday have Level 5 capability and has told government regulators that it would not.
General Motors Super Cruise
General Motors offers its advanced driver assistance system, an SAE Level 2 system called Super Cruise. Like Tesla’s Autopilot, Super Cruise includes an adaptive cruise control that will speed up and slow down the vehicle to maintain a driver-selected distance from the car ahead. It also has a lane-keeping system that tries to center the car in its lane even through curves in the road and automatic emergency braking that brakes the car to avert a collision.
Super Cruise requires the driver to stay alert and keep their hands near the wheel. It includes a driver monitoring system that watches the driver’s eyes and warns them if their attention seems to be drifting from the road. GM says, “Super Cruise allows the driver to drive hands-free when compatible road driving conditions allow the feature to be available. But the driver still needs to pay close attention to the road. Even while using the Super Cruise driver assistance technology, drivers should always pay attention while driving and not use a hand-held device.”
Super Cruise is currently available on most Cadillac vehicles and the Chevy Bolt and Bolt EUV electric vehicles. GM plans to extend it to parts of the Buick and GMC lineup in 2022.
Of note, Super Cruise works only on roads mapped by GM. The company mapped at least 200,000 miles (321,800 kilometres) of roads in the U.S. and Canada using lidar mapping technology.
Ford Blue Cruise
Ford and its Lincoln luxury brand recently introduced their Level 2 automation system, called Blue Cruise. Buyers can order Blue Cruise on many new Ford and Lincoln vehicles today. But the system isn’t active yet. Ford expects to activate it late in 2021 through an over-the-air software update that will not require a visit to the dealership.
Like Tesla’s Autopilot and GM’s Super Cruise systems, Blue Cruise pairs an adaptive cruise control with lane-keeping assistance. It allows drivers to temporarily remove their hands from the wheel while keeping their eyes on the road.
Blue Cruise automatically steers the vehicle using more than 100,000 miles (160,930 kilometres) of pre-mapped roads stored in the system. In Blue Cruise-equipped cars, the driver’s instrument cluster switches to a blue background when driving on a highway where the system can be activated.
Traffic Jam Assists
Luxury automakers have begun developing semi-autonomous driving systems specifically for use in heavy traffic. They allow the driver to relax their attention and let the car accelerate and brake to keep its place in traffic, but systems work only at lower speeds.
BMW’s Active Driving Assistant Pro, for instance, shuts off when traffic exceeds 40 mph (64 km/h). It will not steer the vehicle through curves.
Audi is developing its own Traffic Jam Pilot that, it says, should allow drivers to remove their hands from the wheel below 37 mph (60 km/h). But that system has not received regulatory approval.
The Future of Self-Driving Cars
Engineers from more than a dozen companies are testing self-driving systems in hopes of producing an SAE Level 5 self-driving car. It seems safe to predict that the technology is coming.
But the engineering challenge of getting there is immense. A car that can drive itself on well-maintained roads may make a critical mistake on poorly maintained roads. What if a car that can react safely to regular traffic may not react safely to unusual situations? A vehicle that can do everything engineers asks may fail when presented with a problem they never considered. For example, in one recent incident, a self-driving car in testing was baffled by a truck bed full of traffic signs being delivered to a construction site. The vehicle had no idea what to do.
Beyond the engineering challenge, various sets of local and regional traffic laws must adapt to decide safety and liability issues before self-driving cars become common.
The market will also have its say. Volkswagen recently unveiled a concept car that would charge by the distance driven for self-driving capability. Executives reasoned that as long as getting your car to drive you somewhere costs less than a train ticket to that same place, they could charge for using the self-driving feature. So, while some automakers hope to charge buyers upfront for automation, others may make it available for short-term rental only.
Lastly, there’s the matter of marketing. It’s already growing challenging to sort what manufacturers claim their cars can do from what they can do. That will only grow cloudier as the technology advances.
So, while you may be able to own a self-driving car in your lifetime, it may be further away than advancing technology would indicate.